The Ultimate Comparison: Subtractive vs Fm Synthesis Plugins

by

In the world of music production, synthesizers play a crucial role in shaping sound. Among the various types of synthesis methods, subtractive and frequency modulation (FM) synthesis are two of the most popular techniques. This article provides a comprehensive comparison of subtractive and FM synthesis plugins, helping you understand their differences, applications, and the best plugins available on the market.

Understanding Subtractive Synthesis

Subtractive synthesis is a method where harmonically rich waveforms are generated and then filtered to remove specific frequencies. This technique allows for the creation of a wide range of sounds by manipulating the waveform and applying various filters and modulation.

Key Features of Subtractive Synthesis

  • Utilizes waveforms such as sawtooth, square, and triangle.
  • Employs filters to cut off frequencies, shaping the sound.
  • Involves envelopes and LFOs (Low-Frequency Oscillators) for modulation.
  • Great for creating rich pads, basses, and leads.

Understanding FM Synthesis

Frequency modulation synthesis generates sound by varying the frequency of one waveform (the carrier) with another waveform (the modulator). This method produces complex harmonic and inharmonic sounds that are difficult to achieve with subtractive synthesis.

Key Features of FM Synthesis

  • Creates complex timbres through modulation of frequencies.
  • Utilizes operators, where each operator can be a carrier or modulator.
  • Offers a wide range of sounds, from bells to evolving pads.
  • Requires precise control over parameters for desired results.

Comparison of Subtractive and FM Synthesis

When comparing subtractive and FM synthesis, several factors come into play, including sound design capabilities, ease of use, and typical applications. Here’s a detailed look at how they stack up against each other.

Sound Design Capabilities

Subtractive synthesis excels in creating warm and rich sounds, making it ideal for traditional music styles. FM synthesis, on the other hand, is better suited for creating metallic and bell-like tones, as well as complex evolving sounds.

Ease of Use

Subtractive synthesizers are generally more user-friendly, with intuitive interfaces that allow for quick sound design. FM synthesizers often have a steeper learning curve due to their complex modulation capabilities and parameter settings.

Typical Applications

  • Subtractive synthesis is widely used in genres like pop, rock, and electronic.
  • FM synthesis is prevalent in genres such as ambient, experimental, and video game music.

Here are some of the best subtractive synthesis plugins available today:

  • Sylenth1 – A versatile plugin known for its rich sound and user-friendly interface.
  • Serum – A wavetable synthesizer that combines subtractive and wavetable synthesis.
  • Massive – A powerful synth that excels in bass and lead sounds.
  • Omnisphere – A comprehensive instrument with extensive sound design capabilities.

Here are some of the top FM synthesis plugins worth exploring:

  • FM8 – A classic FM synthesizer with a vast array of sounds and features.
  • Dexed – A free and open-source plugin modeled after the Yamaha DX7.
  • Phase Plant – A modular synth that incorporates FM synthesis among other methods.
  • Vital – A wavetable synthesizer that also offers FM capabilities.

Conclusion

Both subtractive and FM synthesis offer unique advantages for sound design. Subtractive synthesis is ideal for users looking for warmth and ease of use, while FM synthesis is perfect for those seeking complex and evolving sounds. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each method can greatly enhance your music production skills.