Schubert vs Schumann vs Brahms | 3 Great Romantic-Era Composers

Introduction

Franz Schubert, Robert Schumann, and Johannes Brahms are three of the most prominent composers of the Romantic period. Each of these composers contributed significantly to the development of classical music during the 19th century, and their works continue to be widely performed and celebrated today. In this article, we will compare and contrast the styles, techniques, and innovations of Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms.

Composers

Franz Schubert

Franz Peter Schubert was an Austrian composer born on January 31, 1797, in Vienna, Austria. He is widely regarded as one of the most prolific and important composers of the Romantic era, known for his rich melodies, expressive harmonies, and emotional depth in his compositions. Despite his short life, Schubert made a significant impact on the world of classical music and left behind a legacy of over 600 compositions.

Early Years: Schubert’s musical talent became apparent at a young age, and he began receiving music lessons from his father, who was a schoolmaster and amateur musician. At the age of 11, he was admitted to the Imperial and Royal City College of Music in Vienna, where he received a thorough education in music theory and composition. He was heavily influenced by the works of composers such as Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Ludwig van Beethoven, whose music would later inspire his own compositions.

Compositional Output: Schubert composed prolifically throughout his short life, producing a vast array of works in various genres, including symphonies, chamber music, vocal music, and piano music. Some of his most famous compositions include his “Symphony No. 8 in B minor,” commonly known as the “Unfinished Symphony,” “Winterreise,” a song cycle for voice and piano, and his “String Quintet in C Major,” which is considered one of the masterpieces of chamber music.

Schubert’s music is known for its emotional intensity, lyrical melodies, and rich harmonies, which often convey a sense of deep introspection and longing.

Public Recognition: Despite his prolific output, Schubert did not achieve significant public recognition during his lifetime. He struggled financially and relied on the support of friends and family to continue composing. However, he was well-regarded among his close circle of friends, which included other prominent composers and musicians of his time, such as Franz Liszt and Robert Schumann.

Schubert’s music was performed at private gatherings and salons, but he did not gain widespread public recognition during his lifetime.

Later Years and Legacy: Schubert’s health began to deteriorate in his later years, and he died at the age of 31 on November 19, 1828, in Vienna. Despite his relatively short life, Schubert’s music continued to gain recognition after his death. His compositions were gradually published and performed by prominent musicians and ensembles, and his music began to be recognized for its innovative harmonic language, lyrical melodies, and emotional depth.

Today, Schubert is considered one of the greatest composers of the Romantic era, and his works are widely performed and recorded by musicians around the world. His influence can be heard in the works of many later composers, and his music continues to be celebrated for its beauty, expressiveness, and profound emotional impact.

Franz Schubert was a prolific and influential composer of the Romantic era, known for his rich melodies, expressive harmonies, and emotional depth in his compositions. Although he did not achieve significant public recognition during his lifetime, his music gained widespread acclaim after his death, and he is now considered one of the greatest composers in the history of classical music. Schubert’s legacy lives on through his enduring compositions, which continue to be cherished and admired by musicians and audiences alike.

Robert Schumann

Robert Schumann was a German composer and music critic born on June 8, 1810, in Zwickau, Germany. He is known for his profound and emotive compositions, characterized by rich harmonies, lyrical melodies, and complex emotions. Schumann is considered one of the leading composers of the Romantic era, and his works have had a lasting impact on the world of classical music.

Early Years: Schumann showed an early aptitude for music and began piano lessons at a young age. He also displayed a talent for composing, writing his first compositions as a teenager. However, his father’s wishes for him to become a lawyer led him to study law at the University of Leipzig. But his passion for music soon took over, and he pursued a career as a composer and music critic.

Compositional Output: Schumann’s compositions are known for their emotional depth and innovative harmonic language. He wrote prolifically in various genres, including piano music, chamber music, vocal music, and symphonies. Some of his most famous works include “Kinderszenen,” a collection of character pieces for piano, “Dichterliebe,” a song cycle for voice and piano, and his Symphony No. 4 in D minor, known as the “Symphony of a Thousand.” Schumann’s music often conveys a wide range of emotions, from tender lyricism to turbulent intensity, reflecting his complex and introspective nature.

Public Recognition: Schumann’s music was well-received by his contemporaries, and he gained recognition as a prominent composer during his lifetime. He was also known for his music criticism, which was highly influential in shaping the musical tastes of the time. Schumann’s compositions were performed in leading concert halls, and his piano works were particularly admired for their poetic and expressive qualities. However, Schumann also struggled with mental health issues throughout his life, which affected his ability to sustain a successful career as a performer and conductor.

Later Years and Legacy: In his later years, Schumann’s mental health deteriorated further, and he suffered from severe bouts of depression and psychosis. In 1854, he attempted suicide and was subsequently admitted to a mental asylum, where he spent the remaining years of his life. Despite his struggles, Schumann continued to compose during his time in the asylum, producing works of profound beauty and introspection. He died on July 29, 1856, at the age of 46.

Schumann’s music continued to gain recognition after his death. His innovative harmonic language and emotional depth had a profound influence on later composers, such as Johannes Brahms and Gustav Mahler. His piano music is still widely performed and admired for its poetic and expressive qualities, and his song cycles are considered among the masterpieces of the art song repertoire. Schumann’s legacy also extends to his critical writings, which are regarded as important contributions to music journalism and aesthetics.

Robert Schumann was a prolific and influential composer of the Romantic era, known for his emotional depth, innovative harmonic language, and poetic expressiveness in his compositions. His music continues to be celebrated and admired for its profound beauty and introspective nature, and his legacy as a composer and music critic lives on through his enduring works and writings. Now that you’ve learned about Schubert and Schumann, let’s learn about Brahms.

Johannes Brahms

Johannes Brahms was a German composer and pianist born on May 7, 1833, in Hamburg, Germany. He is known for his deeply emotional and intricate compositions, characterized by rich harmonies, lush melodies, and meticulous craftsmanship. Brahms is considered one of the greatest composers of the Romantic era, and his works are regarded as masterpieces of classical music.

Early Years: Brahms displayed prodigious musical talent at a young age and began playing piano and composing as a child. He received formal training in music from prominent musicians of his time and showed a particular affinity for the piano. He also gained recognition as a virtuoso pianist, performing in concerts across Europe. Brahms’ early compositions showed remarkable maturity and originality, and he quickly gained a reputation as a promising young composer.

Compositional Output: Brahms composed in a wide variety of genres, including symphonies, chamber music, choral works, and piano music. His music is known for its emotional depth, structural complexity, and technical mastery. Brahms was deeply influenced by the music of the past, particularly that of Johann Sebastian Bach and Ludwig van Beethoven, and his works often pay homage to these composers while also pushing the boundaries of traditional forms. Some of his most famous works include his Symphony No. 1 in C minor, the Violin Concerto in D major, and the German Requiem, a choral work of profound spiritual and emotional depth.

Public Recognition: Brahms’ music was initially met with mixed reactions from the public and critics. Some found his compositions too complex and conservative, while others appreciated his innovative approach to traditional forms. However, Brahms’ reputation as a composer grew steadily over time, and he eventually gained widespread recognition as one of the leading composers of his era. His music was performed in prestigious concert halls, and he became known as a highly respected conductor as well. Brahms’ piano works were particularly admired for their technical challenges and poetic expressiveness, and his symphonies were considered among the pinnacle of the Romantic symphonic repertoire.

Later Years and Legacy: In his later years, Brahms became more reclusive and focused primarily on composing. He continued to write prolifically, producing a wide range of works that demonstrated his mastery of various forms and genres. Brahms’ compositions from this period are often characterized by their introspective and autumnal qualities, reflecting his mature and contemplative outlook on life. He died on April 3, 1897, in Vienna, Austria, at the age of 63.

Brahms’ music had a profound and lasting impact on the world of classical music. His compositions are revered for their emotional depth, technical mastery, and profound beauty. Brahms’ music bridged the gap between the Romantic and Classical eras, incorporating elements of both while also pushing the boundaries of traditional forms.

His innovative harmonic language and structural complexity had a significant influence on subsequent generations of composers, including Gustav Mahler, Antonín Dvořák, and Richard Strauss. Brahms’ legacy as one of the greatest composers in the history of classical music continues to be celebrated, and his works are widely performed and admired by musicians and audiences alike.

Comparison

One of the key differences between these composers is their approach to melody. Schubert’s melodies are often characterized by their lyricism and expressiveness, with a focus on creating beautiful, singable tunes. Schumann’s melodies, on the other hand, are often more complex and unconventional, with unexpected twists and turns that create a sense of tension and drama. Brahms’ melodies are often characterized by their complexity and richness, with intricate harmonies that create a sense of depth and sophistication.

Another difference between these composers is their approach to harmony. Schubert’s harmonies are often simple and straightforward, with a focus on creating a sense of beauty and emotion. Schumann’s harmonies, on the other hand, are often more complex and dissonant, with a focus on creating a sense of tension and drama. Brahms’ harmonies are often characterized by their richness and complexity, with a focus on creating a sense of depth and sophistication.

In terms of form, Schubert is known for his use of the sonata form in his chamber music and symphonies. This form typically consists of three or four movements, with the first movement featuring a sonata-allegro form. Schumann, on the other hand, is known for his use of cyclic form, in which themes and motifs from earlier movements are repeated and developed throughout the work. Brahms is known for his use of complex and intricate forms, such as the theme and variations, rondo, and fugue.

Schubert is also known for his use of programmatic music, or music that tells a story or evokes a specific image or mood. This can be seen in his song cycles, such as Winterreise and Die schöne Müllerin, which tell the stories of heartbreak and longing. Schumann also experimented with programmatic music, such as in his piano cycle Carnaval, which depicts the characters and events of a masked ball. Brahms, on the other hand, was less interested in programmatic music and focused more on abstract forms and musical structures.

Another significant difference between these composers is their use of instrumentation. Schubert was known for his skillful use of the piano in his chamber music and lieder, often using it to create complex textures and harmonies. Schumann, a skilled pianist himself, also placed great emphasis on the piano in his music, often using it as a solo instrument or as the foundation for his chamber works. Brahms, on the other hand, was known for his skillful use of the orchestra, particularly in his symphonies and concertos, where he created rich, intricate textures and colors.

Despite their differences, Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms all shared a deep appreciation for the emotional and expressive power of music. They all used music as a means of exploring the human experience, delving into the depths of human emotion and the complexities of the human psyche. They also all contributed significantly to the development of classical music during the Romantic period, pushing the boundaries of form, harmony, and instrumentation and paving the way for future generations of composers.

Comparing Compositions

Let’s compare three compositions by Franz Schubert, Robert Schumann, and Johannes Brahms, respectively: Schubert’s “String Quintet in C Major,” Schumann’s “Fantasy in C Major, Op. 17” for piano, and Brahms’ “Symphony No. 4 in E minor, Op. 98.”

Franz Schubert – String Quintet in C Major

Scubert wrote over 1,000 composition spanning a wide range of genres, including symphonies, chamber music, piano music, choral works, songs (lieder), and operas. We’ll focus on FranzSchubert’s “String Quintet in C Major” is a chamber work composed in 1828.

It is considered one of his masterpieces. It is scored for two violins, viola, and two cellos. The piece consists of four movements: Allegro ma non troppo, Adagio, Scherzo (Presto), and Allegretto.

Musical Analysis:

• The quintet opens with a bright and lyrical theme introduced by the first violin, followed by the other instruments. The theme is characterized by its graceful melodies and flowing passages.
• The Adagio movement is a slow and expressive piece with a poignant melody that is passed between the instruments, creating a sense of intimacy and melancholy.
• The Scherzo is a lively and energetic movement with a playful and virtuosic character. It features intricate and rhythmically complex passages in the strings, creating a sense of buoyancy and joy.
• The final Allegretto is a dance-like movement with a folk-like melody, evoking a sense of rustic charm and simplicity. It features a lively and spirited theme that is developed throughout the movement, building to a triumphant and exuberant conclusion.

Robert Schumann – Fantasy in C Major, Op. 17

Schumann’s “Fantasy in C Major, Op. 17” is a solo piano work composed in 1836. It is a large-scale piece consisting of three interconnected movements: Durchaus phantastisch und leidenschaftlich vorzutragen (Fantastically and passionately played throughout), Mäßig. Durchaus energisch (Moderately. With great energy), and Langsam getragen. Durchweg leise zu halten (Slowly carried. Throughout, to be played quietly).

Musical Analysis:

• The Fantasy begins with a sweeping and dramatic theme introduced by the right hand of the piano, followed by cascading arpeggios and expressive melodies in the left hand. The music is characterized by its emotional intensity and virtuosic piano writing.
• The second movement is a contrasting piece with a brisk tempo and lively rhythms. It features bold and vigorous passages, showcasing the technical prowess of the pianist.
• The final movement is a slow and introspective piece with a gentle and haunting melody. It features delicate phrasing and expressive nuances, creating a sense of intimacy and introspection. The piece gradually builds to a powerful climax before subsiding into a serene and peaceful conclusion.

Johannes Brahms – Symphony No. 4 in E minor, Op. 98

Brahms’ “Symphony No. 4 in E minor, Op. 98” is a large-scale orchestral work composed in 1884-1885. It is scored for a standard symphony orchestra and consists of four movements: Allegro non troppo, Andante moderato, Allegro giocoso, and Allegro energico e passionato.

Musical Analysis:

The symphony opens with a somber and majestic theme introduced by the strings, followed by the woodwinds and brass. The theme is characterized by its melancholic and introspective nature, and it undergoes various transformations throughout the movement, including a stirring and triumphant conclusion.

The second movement is a serene and lyrical piece with a rich and expressive melody. It is accompanied by lush harmonies and orchestral colors, creating a sense of warmth and nostalgia. The movement features intricate contrapuntal passages and a sense of graceful flow. The third movement is a lively and playful scherzo with a buoyant and rhythmic character. It features syncopated rhythms, playful melodies, and virtuosic passages in the woodwinds and strings, creating a sense of energy and joy.

The final movement is a powerful and dramatic piece with a sense of urgency and passion. It features a majestic and sweeping theme introduced by the brass, followed by virtuosic passages in the strings and woodwinds. The movement builds to a climactic and triumphant conclusion, with moments of tension and release, before ending in a majestic and resolute manner.

In summary, while all three compositions by Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms showcase their distinct styles and approaches to composition, there are some common elements among them. They all exhibit a deep emotional and expressive quality, with a focus on rich melodies, lush harmonies, and intricate musical structures.

They also demonstrate a high level of virtuosity and technical prowess in their respective instruments or orchestration. Each piece has its own unique characteristics and musical language, but they all share a sense of beauty, depth, and emotional intensity that are characteristic of the Romantic period of classical music.

Conclusion

Franz Schubert, Robert Schumann, and Johannes Brahms were three of the most important composers of the Romantic period, each leaving an indelible mark on the world of classical music. While they each had their own unique style and approach to composition, they all shared a deep appreciation for the emotional and expressive power of music. Their works continue to be celebrated and performed today, inspiring and captivating audiences around the world.

Additional Reading

Breve Music Studios publishes music to Spotify, YouTube Music, Amazon Music and more. Follow our pages on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, and YouTube.

Listen to our ensembles: Breve Orchestra, Breve Music Ensemble, Breve Low Brass Ensemble, Breve Woodwind Ensemble, and Jermaine Harris on Spotify.